Customer satisfaction is at the heart of every successful contact center. However, ensuring that each call meets the highest standards of quality requires structured feedback and actionable insights.

That’s where our Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard comes in, a comprehensive template designed to help contact and call centers assess the performance of individual agents and identify opportunities for improvement.

Why Use a Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard?

A well-crafted evaluation process does more than identify gaps; it drives performance. Our scorecard, allows managers to review individual calls against key performance metrics while fostering an environment of continuous growth and support.

The scorecard evaluates agents’ performance on critical aspects, including:

  • Communication Clarity
  • Problem Resolution
  • Adherence to Protocols
  • Empathy and Tone

By providing objective criteria and actionable feedback, the scorecard becomes a vital tool in developing a high-performing, customer-centric team.

What Is a Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard?

The Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard is a structured framework for reviewing and rating individual calls. It’s designed for supervisors and managers to score agents against predefined benchmarks, ensuring consistency and fairness.

This scorecard goes beyond basic metrics like average handle time or first-call resolution. It provides a holistic view of call quality.

Why Is Call Evaluation Important?

Call evaluations are a cornerstone of any successful contact center strategy. They enable supervisors and managers to benchmark agent performance and identify areas for improvement. By doing so, they can unlock key benefits, including:

  1. Improved Customer Experience: Deliver more consistent, high-quality interactions that satisfy customers.
  2. Employee Development: Provide agents with actionable feedback to enhance their skills and confidence.
  3. Ensured Compliance: Monitor adherence to industry regulations and internal policies.
  4. Consistency Across the Business: Standardize service quality across all teams and channels.
  5. Higher Team Morale: Foster a transparent and supportive environment, boosting employee satisfaction.

What Is in This Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard Template?

Our template is designed to provide clarity, structure, and actionable insights by breaking the evaluation of an individual call into specific sections. Key topics covered include:

  • Greeting and Introduction
  • Account Verification
  • Reason for Call
  • Call Etiquette
  • Script Compliance
  • Closure
  • Observations

Within the template, you can document whether specific benchmarks or expectations were met during the call. Additionally, it provides space to score various aspects of the call, such as the agent’s handling of the customer and their overall knowledge of company policies and procedures, on a scale of 1 to 10.

Based on the agent’s performance, they will receive a score for each section, as well as an overall score and a percentage of criteria met. This detailed breakdown allows you to gain a deeper understanding of performance and identify areas for improvement.

How To Effectively Use Our Call Handling Evaluation Template In Your Business

Using our Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard Template is simple and highly adaptable to meet your contact center’s unique requirements. Here’s how you can make the most of it:

  1. Customisation

Start by making a copy of the Google Sheet template. Tailor it to reflect your business priorities, such as adding custom evaluation criteria, adjusting scoring metrics, or incorporating industry-specific compliance checks.

  1. Evaluation Process

Use the template to evaluate calls in real-time or review recorded interactions for a more detailed analysis.

Assign scores to each section based on predefined benchmarks, ensuring evaluations are consistent and unbiased.

Include comments or notes for each section to highlight strengths and suggest areas for improvement.

  1. Performance Analysis

After scoring, review the overall results to identify patterns or trends, such as recurring challenges or standout performances. Use the percentage of criteria met and the overall scores to benchmark agent performance across your team.

  1. Actionable Insights

Share the results with agents during regular one-on-one reviews or team meetings. Leverage the insights to:

  • Address skill gaps through targeted training programs.
  • Recognise and reward high performers to boost morale.
  • Develop tailored coaching strategies for agents needing support.
  1. Continuous Improvement

Use the data collected from the scorecard to refine your evaluation process over time. Regularly revisit and adjust the template as your business goals, policies, or customer expectations evolve.

By embedding the Call Handling Evaluation Scorecard into your workflows, you’ll foster a culture of continuous improvement, ensure exceptional service quality, and empower your team to thrive in a customer-centric environment.